Zakat - harnessing social impact through charity

Introduction

Forex trading refers to foreign exchange trading where one currency is traded into another. Forex trading is important in the global markets and economy because it not only facilitates international trade, but is also the biggest financial market globally.

A common question is why does forex matter to the global markets? Not only does forex enable international investment and trade it also leads to financial stability. In order to conduct cross-border and cross-country financial transactions, governments and businesses rely on forex. One example of this is where a European company that is importing goods from the USA is able to exchange euros into dollars.

Central banks use forex to stabilise economies when currencies weaken or inflation increases. Forex ensures that money is able to flow across borders.

To decide whether forex trading is haram or halal depends on the the circumstances of the forex trade. We know that any forex trade that includes interest (riba), gambling (maisir) or uncertainty (gharar) could be deemed to be haram. However, when using interest-free accounts, Islamic forex accounts, and Sharia compliant strategies, forex trading can be done in a halal way.

Key Principles of Islamic Finance

What are some of the key Islamic finance principles to be mindful of when examining forex trading?

The main principles you should know about are:

• Prohibition of riba (interest): any kind of interest element attached to a trade is not permissible under Islamic finance rules. Riba is seen as unjustified financial gain and is haram. In forex trading watch out for overnight interest (swap fees) or interest earnt on sums held overnight.
• Avoidance of gharar (uncertainty): any significant uncertainty could render the forex trade haram. Avoid high-risk and speculative trades especially where traders gamble on price movements that have no real economic value. Similarly, avoid traders who trade without any underlying asset (see below). Uncertainty also applies to contract terms. If a trader has hidden fees or complex conditions then this needs to be challenged.
• Avoidance of maisir (speculation/gambling): Islam prohibits gambling and this also applies to trades where financial gains are linked to luck and unearned income. High-frequency and high-risk trades are best avoided.
• Ethical trading: trades and transactions that happen instantly such as spot forex trades (T+ 0 rule) are better than derivatives and futures that relate to settlements in the future.

The Halal Perspective

Forex trading is considered halal when conducted through Islamic accounts with zero interest. There are Islamic forex traders who adopt ethical practices in line with Islamic finance rules, ensuring adherence to Sharia law. The benefit for Muslims is that they can participate in investing and trading without breaching Islamic rules.

As a simple exchange of currencies, the following conditions can render a forex trade halal:

• Islamic swap-free accounts: these accounts are not interest-based and adhere to Islamic finance principles.
• Clear contracts: ensure you have transparent contract terms and pricing with real market involvement.
• Avoid gambling on price movements and work with experienced knowledgeable traders who understand Islamic finance and who are not single-mindedly focused on the margin or return for the parties.
• spot-trading: focus on actual asset ownership and immediate settlement rather than delayed settlements.
• Make sure your dealings are not gambling, but based on legitimate business trades.
• Day trading vs swing trading: day trading includes buying and selling on the same day. No positions are held overnight therefore the chance of incurring interest fees or swap fees is eliminated. Swing trading involves holding positions for many days at a time and this can include interest fees which are haram.

The Haram Perspective

Conventional forex trading is considered to be haram where there is interest payable/charged, and where there are elements of gambling or uncertainty. Always find out as much information you can about the broker, account, process and industry you are engaging with before starting any trading activity.

There are many Islamic brokers and experts that can help you navigate away from haram practices when it comes to currency trading and markets.

Avoid the following practices

1. interest payments.
2. hidden fees.
3. sudden changes in price.
4. manipulations by the brokers
5. excessive uncertainty and ambiguity
6. swap fees (eg overnight payments)
7. exploitation of others in trades
8. trades on market movements without understanding the fundamentals of the market
9. borrowing large amounts of money/ loan (leverage) which is often linked to riba and increased risk

According to Islamic scholars and the Fiqh Council, conventional forex trading is haram when rooted in traditional trading practices. Conventional trading practices go against Islamic beliefs and values relating to financial activities.

However, forex can be halal if:

• you use transparent traders and brokers with Islamic finance knowledge
• you use Islamic accounts with no interest (swap-free accounts)
• you conduct trades on real economic analysis and foundations
• pick Islamic-compliant brokers and organisations
• you avoid speculation, gambling and deception,
• you focus on immediate settlement and future payments
• your trades are based on real asset ownership
• trade using your own capital and not borrowed sums

Frequently Asked Questions

● Is forex trading a form of gambling?

Unless forex trading takes place within an Islamic finance framework (using Islamic accounts and knowledgeable brokers who understand the religious principles of Islam) then it could be deemed to be gambling. When conducted within Sharia rules, forex can be halal.

● How do Islamic accounts work?

Simple speaking, Islamic forex accounts avoid interest payments and interest rate calculations, and are created specifically to comply with Sharia rules about financial transactions.

● Is leverage allowed in Islam?

Leverage refers to traders borrowing money from other brokers to increase their potential profits. In traditional forex trading accounts leverage often includes interest payments on borrowing. Is Islam, leverage is allowed as long as there is no interest payable on leveraged funds.

● Can I trade forex without interest?

Yes, of course. Islamic forex accounts enable Muslims and ethical investors to trade without receiving or paying any interest. Islamic swap-free accounts were created as a solution for Muslim customers and are available on the market that are tailored to ensure they comply with Islamic finance principles.

Conclusion

Ultimately, whether or not forex trading is halal or haram depends on whether the trade itself complies with Islamic finance principles. Islamic scholars and experts can provide guidance and specify trading practices that are haram to help clarify if trading is halal or haram. However, by choosing Sharia-compliant brokers and accounts and focusing on ethical trading there are many ways of engaging in forex trading in a halal way.

There are obvious red flags to avoid for any Muslim (riba being one of them), but there are ways of ensuring that trades are halal. One of the best things you can do before any kind of financial investment or trade is to seek the advice of Islamic scholars and then speak to Muslim forex traders. These people are best placed to ensure that any trade you undertake is halal and remains compliant.

Remember, even Islamic accounts change over time so you need to ensure that there are proper risk management and risk mitigation strategies in place. Exercise caution, if something looks like it is too good to be true then the onus is on you to dig deeper.

WHAT IS STUDENT FINANCE?

Student finance in the United Kingdom is funding that is available for students to access to help cover the cost of their further education. The organisation that is responsible for administering and calculating the extent of the student loan payment is the Student Loans Company.

The Student Loan Company was founded in 1990 and was created to provide students with financial support towards their further education. Currently, student finance can be applied for by students to pay for their university tuition fees and living costs while they are studying.

Every student in the UK is entitled to a loan to cover tuition fees. Tuition fees tend to be decided by the universities and the Student Loan Company will make the payment direct to the educational establishment. Currently, in the UK those studying full time can receive up to £9250 per annum towards tuition fees, and additional funds for living costs known as the maintenance grant.

Repayment Of Student Loans

Student loans need to be repaid in full whether or not the student completes the university course or not. The amount you repay depends on your income and is deducted from your salary in the same way National Insurance and tax are deducted.

You become eligible to repay your student loan (with interest) once your income exceeds a certain threshold. In the UK this threshold is currently around £25,000 per year. Repayments are calculated at 9% on sums over the threshold, and the repayment is subject to interest charges.

WHAT IS MEANT BY HALAL STUDENT FINANCE?

Halal student finance in the UK refers to those financial arrangements that students can access to advance and fund their further education. Any halal student finance or loan needs to be compliant with Islamic finance and Sharia principles relating to money.

Specifically, Islamic student finance means that there should be no interest payable or charged on the loan or fees associated with education. Islamically, interest is considered to be haram and should be avoided at all costs.

The concept of halal student finance is structured to ensure that is adheres to Sharia rules and that the financing of education is compliant with ethical and religious rules. The main principle to be aware of is that the arrangement must not involve any form of interest and the transaction should be non-exploitative and transparent.

For many Muslim students, not having access to halal student finance via the Student Loans Company means they do not pursue their further education goals. The main reason for this is that the current student loan system is based on interest repayments.

Student Loans And Interest

Interest on student loans is an integral part of the system that funds further education. This is generally how student loans operate:

1. Student applies for university, is accepted on to the course, and then makes a student loan application.
2. There are two main elements to the student loan:
3. Tuition fees that cover the cost of the course tuition
4. Maintenance loan that is aimed to help with the living costs including rent, and books.
5. To be eligible for a student loan you need to be resident in the UK and have been accepted on to a course.
6. Repayment of the student loan includes interest and the rate of interest depends on factors such as when you took out the student loan. Repayment only begins post graduation and once you earn over a certain threshold.
7. Interest on the loan accrues from when you receive the funds until the full loan is repaid.

In addition to student loans, there are also scholarships and bursaries available for some students. Postgraduates can also apply for student finance but whether they receive it or not depends on their circumstances.

Before considering any form of loan it is important for you to gather all the information relating to the loan and how it impacts you now and in the future. Whilst many see student loans as an investment in the future, there have been concerns raised about the inability of Muslim students to access student finance.

WHY IS IT IMPORTANT FOR MUSLIM STUDENTS TO ACCESS HALAL STUDENT FINANCE?

Muslims want to be able enter and partake in higher education without breaching Sharia rules. Currently, as the UK student loan system is interest-based, this precludes many Muslims from being able to access the funding they need to study further.

Islam prohibits interest and at the moment there is no interest-free funding option for students. There is a need for student finance based on Islamic finance principles that form part of the student loan scheme in the UK.

It's not only the interest element that is a problem for Muslim students. The existing student loan system is subject to change and this could fall into the remit of gharar (uncertainty) in Islam which is discouraged.

Without doubt, a halal payment system for Muslim students will facilitate greater inclusion in the education system.

Islamic Finance And Student Loans

Some key features of a halal student loan include the following:

• interest free loans: it goes without saying that any form of student finance must ensure there is no interest being charged or paid in order for the loan to be deemed halal. Instead, what is expected to happen is that the lending institution or bank charges fees or alternative structures to fund the transaction.
• Ethical: halal student finance cannot be unethical. This goes against the basic Islamic finance principles. Any halal form of finance or funding needs to steer clear of haram industries such as gambling, porn, and alcohol.
• Transparent: for a student loan arrangement to be compliant with Sharia rules, it must be transparent and clear. Both parties in the transaction should fully understand the terms which themselves should be clear and non-ambiguous.
• Risk and profit sharing: a key component of Islamic finance is that there is adequate profit and risk sharing between the parties. The student should not bare all the responsibility and risk in this kind of arrangement.

Consultation On Halal Student Finance

In 2014 the government launched a consultation relating to Islamic finance based student loans. What they found was that of the 20,000 respondents, over 90% stated that there was a demand for Sharia compliant student finance.

In March 2023 the government in the UK (having consulted on lifelong loan entitlement) confirmed that although a Sharia compliant student finance product was not available, it was committed to funding an alternative form of finance for students.

The government discussed several criteria that should be applied in a halal student finance system including:

• repayments should be easy to make
• any alternative system should be operated through the student loans company
• debt and repayment levels should be the same as they are for other students
• the service should be easy to use and transparent

Halal Student Finance And The Takaful System

At the time they were considering halal student finance options, the government concluded that a takaful system would be most appropriate. In Islam takaful refers to Islamic insurance and is based on cooperation and mutuality.

Takaful systems operate without insurance or gharar.

Unfortunately, no halal student finance option ever really emerged. Instead the government focused on other areas of student finance and simply concluded that they would continue to consider halal student loans.

Whilst government controlled and regulated student loans may not be available as yet, there are still halal finance options available. Some financial institutions are offering Sharia compliant loans that could be used for education.

Tips For Students Who Want Halal Student Finance

For students who are looking for halal student finance alternatives, here are some options you can consider:

• Research Islamic finance products and services, including this Sharia-compliant investment guide
• Look into Islamic scholarships
• Speak with Islamic finance advisors
• Speak to your university finance team and ask them for details of hardship funds or grants
• Consider interest-free loans from family

None of the above are ideal for Muslim students but could provide alternative halal funding for further study.

The future of halal student finance is dependent on many factors including the demand, the economic landscape, and the continued growth of Islamic finance. The Islamic finance industry is innovative and dynamic and could partner up with educational establishments in the future.

Increased awareness and education about the need for halal student loans is also something that could potentially speed up the availability of halal loans. Muslim students need to stay informed and alert and always explore all the options available to them before deciding against pursuing further education.

Debt or Equity in Islam?Non-interest debt financing and equity financing have both been permitted in Islam. It is no surprise that there is no explicit or implicit text giving one form of financing preference over the other. Financing is part of business activity which is highly contextual and variable depending where the business is in its lifecycle. Whilst equity financing might be the only reasonable method for a start-up, an established business would generally seek debt-based financing.
It is from the beauty and comprehensive nature of Islam that no such stipulation to adopt a particular form of financing is found. If we were bound to get one type of financing only, it would put businesses into difficulty. Shariah has given us some principles with which we need to adhere to. Debt is discouraged when there is no strategy to service it. Likewise, taking on debt when it is unmanageable and beyond one's capacity to repay is also discouraged. Beyond that, it is an economic and business decision which the business can make considering what is in its best interest.Business ConsiderationsDebt vs Equity Financing – which is best for your business and why? The simple answer is that it depends. The equity versus debt decision relies on a large number of factors such as the current economic climate, the business’ existing capital structure, and the business’ life cycle stage. Some of the key factors to consider are[1]:

• The cost of finance: Debt finance is usually cheaper than equity finance. This is because debt finance is safer from a lender’s point of view. From a conventional perspective, interest has to be paid before dividend. From a Shariah perspective, debt and profit in Shariah compliant debt-based products is paid off first. In the event of liquidation, debt finance is paid off before equity. This makes debt a safer investment than equity and hence debt investors demand a lower rate of return than equity investors. Interest debt is also corporation tax deductible (unlike equity dividends) making it even cheaper to a taxpaying company. Arrangement costs are usually lower on debt finance than equity finance and once again, unlike equity arrangement costs, they are also tax deductible.
• The current capital gearing of the business: Although debt is attractive due to its cheap cost, its disadvantage is that an additional return has to be paid. If too much is borrowed, then the company may not be able to meet interest and principal payments and liquidation may follow. The level of a company’s borrowings is usually measured by the capital gearing ratio (the ratio of debt finance to equity finance) and companies must ensure this does not become too high. Comparisons with other companies in the industry or with the company’s recent history are useful here.
• Security available: Many lenders will require assets to be pledged as security against loans. Good quality assets such as land and buildings provide security for borrowing - intangible assets such as capitalised research and development expenditure usually do not. In the absence of good asset security, further borrowing may not be an option.It is also possible to offer unsecured financing. Unsecured financing is Shariah compliant as long as the other principles of financing are met. To mitigate the credit risk in unsecured financing, a director can give a personal guarantee.
• Business risk: Business risk refers to the volatility of operating profit. Companies with highly volatile operating profit should avoid high levels of borrowing as they may find themselves in a position where operating profit falls and they cannot meet the interest bill. High-risk ventures are normally financed by equity finance, as there is no legal obligation to pay equity dividend.
• Operating gearing: Operating gearing refers to the proportion of a company’s operating costs that are fixed as opposed to variable. The higher the proportion of fixed costs, the higher the operating gearing. Companies with high operating gearing tend to have volatile operating profits. This is because fixed costs remain the same, no matter the volume of sales. Thus, if sales increase, operating profit increases by a larger percentage. But if sales volume falls, operating profit falls by a larger percentage. Generally, it is a high-risk policy to combine high financial gearing with high operating gearing. High operating gearing is common in many service industries where many operating costs are fixed.
• Dilution of earnings per share (EPS): Large issues of equity could lead to the dilution of EPS if profits from new investments are not immediate. This may upset shareholders and lead to falling share prices.
• Voting control: A large issue of shares to new investors could alter the voting control of a business. If the founding owners hold over 50% of the equity, they may be reluctant to sell new shares to outside investors as their voting control at the AGM may be lost. This would make equity financing disliked for the current shareholders and debt would be preferred.
• The current state of equity markets: In a period of falling share prices many companies will be reluctant to sell new shares. They feel the price received will be too low. This will dilute the wealth of the existing owners. Note this does not apply to rights issues where shares are sold to the existing owners of the company.

ConclusionThese are some of the many considerations which businesses need to consider before raising equity or debt financing. This shows that the decision of debt and equity is not something set in stone from a Shariah perspective; as long as the debt-financing and equity financing are Shariah compliant, the business is at liberty to choose what is most favourable for their purpose and objective. From an investor’s perspective, they should ensure that the business is Shariah compliant and that it has passed the Shariah screening criteria. This can be ascertained by the review from a Shariah advisor.
[1]https://www.accaglobal.com/ca/en/student/exam-support-resources/fundamentals-exams-study-resources/f...