Green investments lead to sustainability and growth

The COVID-19 pandemic has not only resulted in a public health crisis, but has also increased poverty levels and accelerated inequalities across the world. According to a recent survey of 37 countries[1], since the start of the pandemic:

• 3 in 4 households suffered a reduction in income with 82% of poorer households affected.
• Gender inequalities are on the rise due to consumer-facing industries being hit the hardest.
• Minorities in high income countries have been hit hardest as they live in areas that have been most vulnerable to the health and economic impacts of the pandemic.
• Inequality is also rising between countries as high-income countries have been better placed to provide financial & social safety nets to counter the crisis relative to poorer countries.

On the other end, the wealth gap is also widening as billionaires saw their wealth rise 27.5% to £7.9trn between April to July this year with their total numbers increasing to a record 2,189 (2,158 in 2017)[2]. This generally reflects the strong performance in global stock markets since the start of the pandemic.

As nations across the world attempt to cope with the crisis, they might be able to draw upon mechanisms that were used historically in the Muslim world in order to reduce poverty and income inequalities. Some of these mechanisms highlighted below, when used correctly, might serve to soften the blow by allowing for the systematic redistribution of wealth in society. These include amongst others access to a unique financing type as well as well as other mechanisms for income redistribution:

• Qard Hasan (benevolent loan) is a loan that is extended from a lender to a borrower for social welfare purposes. Through this mechanism the rich are encouraged to extend loans to the needy. The lender has no right to demand any amount in excess of the original principal amount as that would violate the prohibition on Riba (interest or usury). When used on a broad scale, this type of financing serves as a tool to not only reduce income inequality and alleviate poverty but also promote financial inclusion.
• Zakat and al-Khums (compulsory charity) and Sadaqa (voluntary charity) are mechanisms for income redistribution from the rich to the poor. Zakat, for example, a mandatory almsgiving that requires Muslims who own wealth at or above a certain threshold to donate a portion of it, typically 2.5%, to those who are eligible.[3]
• Historically, Awqaf (endowments) or the waqf (singular) played a pivotal role in socio-economic development across the Muslim world. They were important Islamic financial institutions that mobilized and facilitated the flow of funds towards philanthropic causes such as in order to fund education, health & libraries amongst others.

To varying degrees, some of these mechanisms are currently being used in various parts of the world, whereas others (ex. Waqf) are no longer as prevalent as they once were. Having said that, more has to be done as nearly all economic indicators suggest we have reached a tipping point with high levels of poverty and income inequality across the world. Efforts by policy makers to address these issues by preempting them could involve integrating such mechanisms as well as others in order to allow for a more equitable distribution of wealth and income. This in turn would create the foundations for resilient systems that are better able to cope with shocks as they appear.

[1]https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/10/covid-19-is-increasing-multiple-kinds-of-inequality-here-s-wh...[2]https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-54446285[3]https://nzf.org.uk/about-zakat/purpose-of-zakat/

WHAT IS A VENTURE CAPITAL TRUST?

A venture capital trust (VCT) is essentially an investment company. In the UK the government introduced VCTs in 1995 as a way of ensuring that investors could invest in start-up companies. The government was keen to encourage investment in entrepreneurial businesses by offering tax relief to investors. Recently there has been discussion and debate about whether VCTs are halal or haram.

For new businesses, VCTs are a great way of raising investment, and for investors they are an opportunity to invest in upcoming businesses.

For anyone looking for Sharia compliant investing, VCTs can be a good opportunity to invest in a halal way. Investing in VCTs can be halal, but you have to ensure that the VCT you invest in complies with Sharia rules about investment and financial transactions.

In recent years, as the Islamic finance market has expanded so too has the desire for Sharia compliant VCTs. The Islamic VCT market is innovative and presents a viable alternative to conventional investment models which are not always acceptable to Muslims who want to invest in line with Sharia rules.

Whilst it is always a personal choice as to where investors want to invest, for Muslims there are additional considerations that require them to be mindful of Islamic laws.

Let's have a look at how VCTs work and how they can operate in a halal way.

HOW DO VENTURE CAPITAL TRUSTS WORK?

VCTs work by raising money and then using the funds to invest in new and innovative companies. Usually these companies are innovative and privately owned. The idea is that the investment raised is then used to generate a profit and solid return for the investment.

The company can be dealing in products and services, offering employment opportunities, and/or meeting a need in the economy. The number of companies seeking investment is never-ending.

As an investor in a VCT, the investor becomes a shareholder of the trust. It is important to note that the investor does not become a shareholder of each individual company, rather the investor becomes a shareholder of the trust in its entirety.

Most VCTs will invest in different companies. This enables the VCT to keep its investment portfolio options diverse and spreads the risk. It is always important to ensure you have all the information you need about the VCT before investing.

When the companies within the trust return a profit, this is paid over to the shareholders.

WHAT DO VENTURE CAPITAL TRUSTS INVEST IN?

Most VCTs will invest in new, small, and entrepreneurial companies across a wide variety of sectors. These can include tech companies, retail, clothing brands, food outlets and many more.

Many of these companies will be privately owned, and some of them are quoted on the Alternative Investment Market or the London Stock Exchange.

Different Types Of Venture Capital Trusts

There are some different types of VCTs. What differentiates them from each other is the investment focus and area:

• specialist VCTs : these are VCTs that remain focused on a specific interest and sector. For example, there are VCTs that only invest in healthcare, or retail. Due to the lack of choice and sector diversification, this often means that they can carry more risk.
• Generalist VCTs : these types of VCT are wide-ranging when it comes to investment. They invest in companies across different sectors. The value to the investor is that there is diversification and less risk.
• AIM VCTs : the Alternative Index Market (AIM) VCTs invest in shares issued by AIM quoted companies. The AIM was set up by the London Stock Exchange in 1995 to ensure that there was a market for companies who can't (or won't) meet the demanding requirements for listing on the London Stock Exchange.

Venture Capital Trusts And Tax Advantages

One of the main reasons VCTs are popular is that they offer tax incentives. Investors can take advantage of:

• tax free dividends
• up to 30% income tax relief
• tax free growth
• capital gains tax exemptions and deferrals

WHAT IS VENTURE CAPITAL TRUST TAX RELIEF?

VCT tax relief can be claimed when an income tax return is filed with HMRC.

What this means for investors is that they can end up with a lower income tax bill, or even a refund if they have already paid their tax.

Islamic Finance And Venture Capital Trusts

Remember, one of the most critical elements of ensuring compliance with Sharia law when investing in venture capital trusts is that you need to work with a Sharia aware, and Sharia compliant, financial advisor.

This will ensure that the investment contract AND investment models are both compliant with Islamic finance rules.

Islamic Venture Capital Trusts Vs Conventional Capital Trusts

The main difference between conventional VCTs and Islamic VCTs is that Islamic VCTs must comply with Islamic finance rules relating to finance and financial transactions.

Islamic VCTs need to stay away from any form of investment in non-permissible, or haram, industries.

A very simple example of this would be as follows: a conventional VCT could invest in brewery shares. However, an Islamic VCT should stay away from any alcohol related industry.

Going further, anyone looking to invest in Sharia compliant VCTs should do additional due diligence and ask questions about the company they invest in. Does it operate ethically? Does it have conventional debts on its book that is interest-based? If so, then the VCT is not considered to be halal.

Advantages Of Investing In Venture Capital Trusts For Muslims

As long as the VCT is Sharia compliant, Muslim investors offer a diverse range of investment options. Muslim investors can take advantage of investing in other Muslim businesses and industries.

There are numerous ethical investment opportunities with halal VCTs that are attractive to Muslims. Socially responsible investing is a core principle of Islamic finance and there are VCTs out there that are ethical and socially responsible.

Halal VCTs also offer the potential for job creation with early stage companies. Supporting these businesses mean Muslims can indirectly be helping struggling economies and economic development. This aligns with the Islamic finance principles that relate to promoting economic wellbeing and financial inclusion.

WHAT IS WAKALA?

Wakala is a popular model Islamic VCTs when it comes to raising capital.

Wakala permits the asset manager of the trust (on behalf of the investor) to act on their behalf based on agreed conditions and terms.

Both parties then share the profits generated, and take on the risk of any losses together. This kind of profit and loss sharing arrangement aligns with Islamic finance principles.

Mudaraba And Venture Capital Trusts

When it comes to investing in start up companies, mudaraba is a common model that is used. The mudaraba contract is a contract that enables one party to the contract to bring assets in and for the other party to bring in effort and experience.

This means that investor provides the financing, and the entrepreneur takes responsibility for the day to day management of the trust. The contract outlines the respective responsibilities of each party and the profit sharing arrangement.

As already mentioned, despite the many advantages of halal VCTs, investors need to work with Sharia compliant advisors who can direct them to halal VCTs.

Consulting with knowledgeable advisors means you have specific guidance and adherence to Sharia rules.

WHAT IS STUDENT FINANCE?

Student finance in the United Kingdom is funding that is available for students to access to help cover the cost of their further education. The organisation that is responsible for administering and calculating the extent of the student loan payment is the Student Loans Company.

The Student Loan Company was founded in 1990 and was created to provide students with financial support towards their further education. Currently, student finance can be applied for by students to pay for their university tuition fees and living costs while they are studying.

Every student in the UK is entitled to a loan to cover tuition fees. Tuition fees tend to be decided by the universities and the Student Loan Company will make the payment direct to the educational establishment. Currently, in the UK those studying full time can receive up to £9250 per annum towards tuition fees, and additional funds for living costs known as the maintenance grant.

Repayment Of Student Loans

Student loans need to be repaid in full whether or not the student completes the university course or not. The amount you repay depends on your income and is deducted from your salary in the same way National Insurance and tax are deducted.

You become eligible to repay your student loan (with interest) once your income exceeds a certain threshold. In the UK this threshold is currently around £25,000 per year. Repayments are calculated at 9% on sums over the threshold, and the repayment is subject to interest charges.

WHAT IS MEANT BY HALAL STUDENT FINANCE?

Halal student finance in the UK refers to those financial arrangements that students can access to advance and fund their further education. Any halal student finance or loan needs to be compliant with Islamic finance and Sharia principles relating to money.

Specifically, Islamic student finance means that there should be no interest payable or charged on the loan or fees associated with education. Islamically, interest is considered to be haram and should be avoided at all costs.

The concept of halal student finance is structured to ensure that is adheres to Sharia rules and that the financing of education is compliant with ethical and religious rules. The main principle to be aware of is that the arrangement must not involve any form of interest and the transaction should be non-exploitative and transparent.

For many Muslim students, not having access to halal student finance via the Student Loans Company means they do not pursue their further education goals. The main reason for this is that the current student loan system is based on interest repayments.

Student Loans And Interest

Interest on student loans is an integral part of the system that funds further education. This is generally how student loans operate:

1. Student applies for university, is accepted on to the course, and then makes a student loan application.
2. There are two main elements to the student loan:
3. Tuition fees that cover the cost of the course tuition
4. Maintenance loan that is aimed to help with the living costs including rent, and books.
5. To be eligible for a student loan you need to be resident in the UK and have been accepted on to a course.
6. Repayment of the student loan includes interest and the rate of interest depends on factors such as when you took out the student loan. Repayment only begins post graduation and once you earn over a certain threshold.
7. Interest on the loan accrues from when you receive the funds until the full loan is repaid.

In addition to student loans, there are also scholarships and bursaries available for some students. Postgraduates can also apply for student finance but whether they receive it or not depends on their circumstances.

Before considering any form of loan it is important for you to gather all the information relating to the loan and how it impacts you now and in the future. Whilst many see student loans as an investment in the future, there have been concerns raised about the inability of Muslim students to access student finance.

WHY IS IT IMPORTANT FOR MUSLIM STUDENTS TO ACCESS HALAL STUDENT FINANCE?

Muslims want to be able enter and partake in higher education without breaching Sharia rules. Currently, as the UK student loan system is interest-based, this precludes many Muslims from being able to access the funding they need to study further.

Islam prohibits interest and at the moment there is no interest-free funding option for students. There is a need for student finance based on Islamic finance principles that form part of the student loan scheme in the UK.

It's not only the interest element that is a problem for Muslim students. The existing student loan system is subject to change and this could fall into the remit of gharar (uncertainty) in Islam which is discouraged.

Without doubt, a halal payment system for Muslim students will facilitate greater inclusion in the education system.

Islamic Finance And Student Loans

Some key features of a halal student loan include the following:

• interest free loans: it goes without saying that any form of student finance must ensure there is no interest being charged or paid in order for the loan to be deemed halal. Instead, what is expected to happen is that the lending institution or bank charges fees or alternative structures to fund the transaction.
• Ethical: halal student finance cannot be unethical. This goes against the basic Islamic finance principles. Any halal form of finance or funding needs to steer clear of haram industries such as gambling, porn, and alcohol.
• Transparent: for a student loan arrangement to be compliant with Sharia rules, it must be transparent and clear. Both parties in the transaction should fully understand the terms which themselves should be clear and non-ambiguous.
• Risk and profit sharing: a key component of Islamic finance is that there is adequate profit and risk sharing between the parties. The student should not bare all the responsibility and risk in this kind of arrangement.

Consultation On Halal Student Finance

In 2014 the government launched a consultation relating to Islamic finance based student loans. What they found was that of the 20,000 respondents, over 90% stated that there was a demand for Sharia compliant student finance.

In March 2023 the government in the UK (having consulted on lifelong loan entitlement) confirmed that although a Sharia compliant student finance product was not available, it was committed to funding an alternative form of finance for students.

The government discussed several criteria that should be applied in a halal student finance system including:

• repayments should be easy to make
• any alternative system should be operated through the student loans company
• debt and repayment levels should be the same as they are for other students
• the service should be easy to use and transparent

Halal Student Finance And The Takaful System

At the time they were considering halal student finance options, the government concluded that a takaful system would be most appropriate. In Islam takaful refers to Islamic insurance and is based on cooperation and mutuality.

Takaful systems operate without insurance or gharar.

Unfortunately, no halal student finance option ever really emerged. Instead the government focused on other areas of student finance and simply concluded that they would continue to consider halal student loans.

Whilst government controlled and regulated student loans may not be available as yet, there are still halal finance options available. Some financial institutions are offering Sharia compliant loans that could be used for education.

Tips For Students Who Want Halal Student Finance

For students who are looking for halal student finance alternatives, here are some options you can consider:

• Research Islamic finance products and services
• Look into Islamic scholarships
• Speak with Islamic finance advisors
• Speak to your university finance team and ask them for details of hardship funds or grants
• Consider interest-free loans from family

None of the above are ideal for Muslim students but could provide alternative halal funding for further study.

The future of halal student finance is dependent on many factors including the demand, the economic landscape, and the continued growth of Islamic finance. The Islamic finance industry is innovative and dynamic and could partner up with educational establishments in the future.

Increased awareness and education about the need for halal student loans is also something that could potentially speed up the availability of halal loans. Muslim students need to stay informed and alert and always explore all the options available to them before deciding against pursuing further education.