Ethical Investing: What is it and how does it work?

Introduction

A pension fund is a pool of money that is managed by professional fund managers. The aim of the fund is to save money and invest money in preparation for retirement. A Sharia pension fund is a saving scheme for retirement that aligns with the rules of Islam. Sharia pension funds do not attach themselves to any form of interest or any haram industries.

Sharia pension funds are ethical investments, with funds invested in industries that offer social benefits such as healthcare, agriculture, and education.

With the rise of Islamic finance on a global level and the increased demand for Sharia-compliant financial services, the growth of Sharia pension funds has expanded significantly.

Sharia pension funds will typically have a screening process ensuring they comply with Islamic finance rules. It is important for these types of pension funds to have ongoing compliance monitoring, which means that a qualified Sharia scholar or expert reviews compliance regularly.

In 2024 Sharia pension funds saw significant growth. The Nest Sharia Fund increased its assets by a third to over £180 million.

Historically, Muslims have found it difficult to fund Sharia-compliant funds. The Office for National Statistics found in 2021 that 33% of Muslim employees did not have a workplace pension due to concerns about Sharia-compliance.

These statistics make it clear that there is a huge market for pension funds that comply with Islamic finance principles. Recently, the Financial Times has reported that Sharia pension funds are seeing a huge swell 'amid returns boost'.

WHAT MAKES A PENSION FUND SHARIA-COMPLIANT?

The key features of a Sharia-compliant pension fund are:

• Strictly no interest: the pension fund should have no involvement with interest in any way. This means that any interest-yielding activities, industries or products are not permissible.
• Ethical investing: the pension fund should be mindful of the industries the investments are involved in. Industries and sectors considered haram such as gambling and alcohol should be avoided.
• Compliance: compliance and ongoing monitoring are essential for a Sharia complaint pension fund.
• Sharia screening: financial and ethical screening must take place to ensure that organisations invested in have low levels of overall debt.
• Models of operation: profit-sharing and risk-sharing are the encouraged models of partnership working.

Some examples of Sharia-compliant funds include the following:

• sukuk/Islamic bonds
• investing in property without interest-based loans
• investing in ethical and sustainable industries such as healthcare

Comparing Top Sharia Pension Plans

If you are looking for Sharia-compliant pension funds to ensure you can save for retirement without breaching Islamic rules, then Penfold and Nest pension funds are a good place to start.

Nest Sharia Pension Fund

The Nest Sharia Fund invests in what are known as Islamic bonds (sukuks) that are fully Sharia-compliant. Nest ensures that Islamic scholars screen the investment products and services to ensure they adhere to Islamic rules.

In addition, Nest's Sharia Fund avoids haram industries and interest-bearing investments.

Nest's fee structure consists of a contribution charge (around 1.8%) and an annual management charge in the region of 0.3% based on the value of the fund.

With ethical investments at the core of its activities, the Nest Sharia Fund delivers growth whilst generating income. More recently, Nest has worked on diversifying its investment portfolio to include a 30% allocation to the sukuks it invests it.

Penfold Sharia Pension Fund

The Penfold Sharia Fund invests in a diverse portfolio of companies and funds that all operate in accordance with Sharia principles.

The Penfold fee structure charges an annual fee for savings up to £100k of 0.88%, and this fee drops to 0.53% on amounts over £100k. This transparent and easy to follow fee structure makes this pension fund attractive to investors.

Both these Sharia pension funds use rigorous screening processes that aim to ensure that all investments comply with Islamic finance rules.

If any company they invest in has a proportion of what is considered to be non-compliant income (ie income from interest), then they use purification processes such as donating money to charity.

Investment Risks And Rewards

Sharia pension funds are the same as all investment vehicles on the market. They come with their own unique set of risks and rewards. For Sharia pension funds, the risk management and mitigation strategies should be aligned with Islamic rules.

Sharia pension funds tend to avoid fixed income securities and conventional bonds as these vehicles rely on interest. Instead, Sharia pension funds prefer to invest in Islamic bonds.

Risk

The risk profile for Sharia pension funds can sometimes have a higher risk exposure due to the fact that they stay away from conventional interest-bearing bonds.

Return

In the long term, Sharia-compliant funds deliver comparable and competitive returns to conventional bonds.

Ethical Investments Vs Conventional Funds

It is important to note that Sharia pension funds maintain a balance between competitive financial returns and ethical investment strategies. This makes Sharia funds an attractive option for investors.

If you are looking for investments that focus on societal benefit whilst generating an income (or savings pot) then Sharia pension funds are a great alternative to conventional bonds.

Ethical sectors have seen a massive resurgence in recent years, with strong growth potential. Industries such as renewable energy and technology are prime for investment.

Investors are increasingly considering environmental, social and governance (ESG) factors when examining pension funds.

• Over 89% of investors consider ESG when investing.
• In the UK over 57% of investors now hold ESG investments
• Young Gen Z investors are increasingly interested in ethical investments
• Islamic funds continue to deliver results with nominal growth rates of 84% and 13% of annualised growth rates (Morningstar.CA)

How To Choose And Switch To A Sharia Pension Fund

In order for you to choose a Sharia pension fund you need to ensure you understand what a Sharia pension fund is and how it operates.

If you have a pension fund that you want to switch to a Sharia fund then you need to:

1. Review your current pension fund.
2. Find out if your pension fund provider is able to offer a Sharia-compliant fund.
3. If not, ask if you can switch your pension fund.
4. Check your pension fund information to see if there are any penalties or fees for switching to a Sharia-compliant provider.
5. Research what Sharia pension fund providers are available and make sure they are fully Sharia compliant.
6. Choose your new pension fund provider and open an account.
7. Ask your current pension provider to transfer your fund to the new Sharia-compliant provider.

If you want to transfer a workplace pension then speak to your HR team or your employer to find out if they accept transfers of the fund.

Switching to a Sharia pension fund should be straightforward.

Future Of Sharia Pension Funds

Sharia pension funds are becoming a popular investment vehicle and retirement savings plan for Muslims and non-Muslims. The ethical investment market continues to grow as investors across the world seek out sustainable and ethical investments.

Underpinned by social responsibility, the investments within Sharia pension funds appeal to a global audience of investors.

Sharia funds have become known in financial circles as promoting financial inclusion. They cater to investors who have not been able to fund ethical investments or investments that align with Islamic rules.

If you want to prepare for retirement in a Sharia-compliant way then Sharia pension funds provide the perfect vehicle for you. Providers like Penfold and Nest provide Sharia-compliant pension funds with competitive fees.

Waqf is an ongoing, sustainable, charitable donation and has been used throughout Islamic history to benefit and support communities, and aid community development. Islamically, waqf is a mechanism through which the condition of society can be improved. Waqf refers to an endowment made to a charitable, educational or religious cause.

It is a voluntary action that the whole community can benefit from, for example, the building of a university, research centre or hospital.

WAQF - WHAT DOES IT MEAN?
The Arabic meaning of waqf means 'restriction'. This is based on the principle that all property essentially belongs to Allah. So, whilst a Muslim may donate to a charity for community development, the donation is not owned by the Muslim but by Allah.

For example, if you donate some land or an asset for the purpose of community development, then the community will reap the benefits. The donation releases an ongoing community benefit that supports future generations. A famous example of waqf is the Al Azhar Mosque and University in Cairo, Egypt. This University was founded as waqf in 1908, with funds donated by wealthy Egyptians.

HOW DOES WAQF WORK?
Waqf involves donating a fixed asset which in turn provides a financial return.

Waqf is based on the principle that you can donate an asset that can then continue to provide a charitable service for the foreseeable future. The waqf project goes on to support others in the community through various activities and services.

This is how waqf works:

• Individual donates an asset to a waqf project.
• The donations are collated and invested in a Sharia compliant way.
• Any profits and returns on the investments are used to support charitable organizations such as education, relief of poverty, providing healthcare services and emergency solutions.
• Some profits are reinvested in a Sharia compliant manner.

The outcome is that your donation should keep going for a number of years, benefiting humans for generations. The incentive for Muslims wanting to donate to a waqf is that the donation is considered to be an ongoing charitable endowment that benefits others for many years.

History Of Waqf

Although waqf is not explicitly prescribed in the Quran like charity is, it is considered to be comparable to sadaqah. Waqf investments are deemed to be a crucial part of Islam as the Prophet (SAW) stated that:

"When a person dies, all their deeds end except three: a continuing charity, beneficial knowledge, and a child who prays for them"

Waqf investments have an important continuing charity element.

Waqf As A Social Finance Institution

Many Muslim majority countries in the world are still developing and income-poor. There is a lack of availability of private sector investment businesses and options. Waqf can be considered a social finance institution that can fill the gaps in development spending. Waqf provides an avenue for the effective utilisation of perpetual social savings.

With transnational waqf investments and support programmes, there is potential for philanthropic Muslims to support the development of communities across the world.

When viewed through an Islamic redistribution framework, it is clear that waqf harnesses selfless charitable giving in a way that is effective and impactful. Targeting social segments within society and aiming for long term improvement brings benefits to donors and society as a whole.

Donating assets for permanent societal benefit facilitates flexibility and stabilisation for deprived and needy communities. Waqf essentially transforms social capital into social infrastructure, complementing zakat and sadaqah donations.

Sourcing Sharia compliant waqf investments and donations online can be difficult, so you must ensure that you undertake the due diligence required.

With the financial landscape changing constantly, Muslims are looking out for investments that are profitable and Sharia compliant. With so many Muslim women managing their own finances and the finances of their home, there is an increased demand for halal investments.

Making spiritually aligned investments seems more important than ever in todays society.Whether it is investing in the stock market, the exchange-traded fund, personal savings, having an ISA or looking to invest in real estate, more and more Muslim women are looking for smarter ways to invest.

So, what are the things you need to look out for when considering halal investment? Let's take a look.

Understanding Halal Investments

Halal investments are those financial activities that are compliant with Islamic finance rules and Sharia law. Islamically, financial dealings which are based on interest or speculation are not permitted. This means many Muslims will not invest.

Islamic finance investments are more focused on investments that are ethical and deemed to be socially responsible. That is, they offer some tangible benefit to society and are not exploitative or speculative.

For an investor looking for a halal investment, they need to look out for the following:

• the investment must avoid any form of interest: charging or paying interest is haram in Islam. This means that if you are investing in an industry that includes interest or is deemed to be a haram industry then this is not permitted.
• the investment should avoid any kind of ambiguity: this means that any form of investment in stocks and shares that is akin to gambling is not allowed. There must be clear terms and conditions and transparency in all transactions that relate to any asset or money.
• It is important to avoid haram: this relates to any industry or dealing that is haram.
• social responsibility: it is important to ensure that any investment aligns with your ethical responsibilities under Islam and is socially responsible. To invest in arms production would not be deemed to be halal, nor would investment in the alcohol industry.

Navigating Financial Products That Are Halal

Halal investment can take many different forms. They include the following:

• Islamic banking: banks and other financial institutions often offer services and products that are halal. You can use a Sharia compliant bank account to save your money.
• Islamic mutual funds: these kinds of funds have been vetted to ensure they are Sharia compliant (although you should also make your own enquiries). Islamic mutual funds invest in Sharia compliant industries, markets, and assets. Investors share in the profits generated and also in the losses if they occur.
• Islamic real estate: investments in real estate are becoming more common with the onset of Islamic finance mortgages and funding options.
• Islamic bonds (sukuk): Islamic bonds are the type of financial instruments that are fully compliant with Sharia law. They offer investors ownership in an asset and the profits and revenue are generated by the asset.
• Halal stocks: companies that operate in a halal way offer stocks that can be purchased by investors.
• Exchange-traded funds: you can find halal ETFs on the market if you look carefully. There are many ETF products that invest in a range of halal stocks and other permissible assets.
• Islamic crowdfunding: some platforms are now offering Islamic crowdfunding options and peer lending options from one person to another. If thinking of making an investment on such platforms make sure that they are Sharia compliant.

Empowering Women

There are growing numbers of young professional women who want to invest and manage their money in a Sharia compliant way. For these women investing in halal companies and stocks is not simply about wealth management but also about adherence to the rules of Islam.

The empowerment of women in the financial sector has always been a practice in Islamic societies. The very fact that women often manage the household finances and then have to ensure they have sufficient funds for the charitable payments of zakat, means that women have always been financially literate.

In Islam, mutual consent in financial dealings is one of the central concepts of Islamic finance. This has meant that women have been involved in decisions about payments and finances from the start.

Women And Business In Islam

Historically, Islam has always promoted the independence of women whether that is in the fields of education, trade, and finances. Historical accounts document that Muslim women were engaged in trade and business many centuries ago. For example, the wife of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) was a very successful businesswoman.

Islam has always had legal protections in place for women to protect and grow their finances. These protections have secured Muslim women's rights in marriage, in inheritance, and in succession.

Halal investing is linked to faith and encourages Muslim women to view their wealth as a blessing from God and one that needs to be shared and stored ethically. In Islam, women and business are not mutually exclusive. In fact, Islamic history teaches us that women have always been active participants in the business world.

Islamically, women are entitled to own, invest and manage their own funds.

Explaining Interest-Free Finance

For anyone looking to manage their finances in a Sharia compliant way, the very first step is to ensure you are not charging or paying any form of interest.

Interest free finance operates without including interest in financial transactions. When it comes to investing, it is important that you stay away from interest and any industry that relies heavily on interest or debt based finance.

Interest is seen as very exploitative and unethical.

Interest free finance operates on the basis that both parties to the transaction share the profit and the risk. The focus is on real economic activity that generates profit, rather than using money to create money via interest.

Educating yourselves on the core concepts of Islamic finance will ensure that any investment activity you take part in will be Sharia compliant.

Define Goals And Objectives

Identify what your financial goals and objectives are. Look for a market that appeals to you and aligns with your personal values. This should also apply to other forms of investment such as your pension. Is your pension being invested in companies that align with your ethical position? Always do your due diligence and research the industries your finances are involved with.

Spread your investments. Diversify your portfolio as this will not only reduce your risk but enable you to do more social good with your money. It is not necessarily always the case that investing in one kind of stock or bond will yield the best results.

Look at halal index funds and examine the market of each fund. How do they operate? Where do they operate? what information do you have about the return you will receive? Is the service being offered Sharia compliant? what practices does the industry use? How do they pay?

If any industry is non-compliant with Sharia rules then stay away from it.

The value of your investment should not be based on speculative activities or interest. This applies to any form of investment and savings accounts.

Choosing The Right Provider For Halal Financial Services

It is essential that you consult with Islamic finance experts and scholars if you are unsure of investing. An educated Islamic finance expert will ensure that your investment choice is Sharia compliant and regulated properly in the UK.

Once you have made the investment you must undertake periodic evaluations. Regularly reviewing your investment portfolio will ensure it continues to align with your ethical and financial goals. Don't assume that an investment will remain Sharia compliant throughout its lifetime. Companies change course depending on the economy so keep an eye on the Sharia compliancy.

Aligning Values With Ethics And Wealth

When it comes to aligning values with ethics and wealth, Muslim women are embracing the principles of Islamic finance and Sharia compliant investment. Whilst Islam is centred around the the 5 pillars (declaration of faith, prayer, charity, fasting, and hajj pilgrimage), Muslims are also expected to follow the Sharia.

Pursuing halal investment and savings not only ensures that you live a Sharia compliant lifestyle, but also ensures that you live a more meaningful and ethical life.

It is essential to educate yourself and gain an understanding of Islamic finance principles. Stay informed about the different financial instruments that are available and assess them for compliance with Islamic principles. Screen investments and work with companies who also align themselves with Islamic finance rules.

The world of Islamic finance based investments is widening year on year, so there are plenty of options available out there. Regularly review your investment portfolio and make any adjustments you need to. Finally, be patient and be ethical.

Qardus do not provide financial or investment advice.