Are venture capital trusts halal?

As e-commerce businesses and platforms continue to increase and develop, one of the main challenges these businesses face is securing financial backing. E-commerce platforms and websites such as Shopify have grown exponentially in the last decade, and this is in part due to the change in consumer behaviour with increasing amounts of money being spent on online shopping. As consumers have flocked online to purchase what they need, especially during the Covid-19 pandemic, the e-commerce market has grown quickly to meet the demand.

In addition to consumer demand, another reason for the growth in e-commerce ventures and transactions is the fact that e-commerce trading is accessible to all. Online businesses are democratised, enabling all entrepreneurs equal access to entry when it comes to selling products and services. However, like traditional businesses, e-commerce enterprises need funding in order to grow. Arguably, the financial world is still trying to catch up with the growth of e-commerce in terms of the funding options available. The finance world is continuing to evolve to ensure that it meets the needs of e-commerce retail businesses that operate via web pages and online sales.

Not having the capital funding and investment available is one of the main reasons that prohibit online ventures from succeeding. With consumers in the United Kingdom spending over £1 billion online every week, e-commerce funding has become a growing market. However, with less hard assets as traditional bricks-and-mortar businesses, e-commerce ventures may find it harder to find and secure the funding they need to expand and meet the needs of the economy.

When To Start Raising Funding

For any business venture, the best time to think about funding and finance is when the business idea is developed. Once you are clear about your business goals and aims, you should work out how much money you will need to achieve those goals. Securing funding not only enhances the chances of success, but also ensures you have the capital to build and execute your business strategy.

The type of funding you opt for depends on what type of business you have, your business needs, whether you want to ensure you keep full ownership, and what the funding is needed for.

Why E-Commerce Businesses Need Funding

You might be wondering whether a business venture that operates online requires funding? After all, many e-commerce businesses may not need the levels of inventory required by traditional businesses. Online ventures also do not have the extensive costs of property rental or asset management, but they do have the technology and software to function well on the internet and provide the best end user experience.

E-commerce funding is essential because it facilitates growth. Capital funding means the business can cover its expenses that can include marketing costs, operational expenses, and costs of operating via online platforms. E-commerce businesses have similar expenses and outlays to other businesses.

Many traditional funding options such as bank loans simply do not meet the needs of digital e-commerce business models and ventures. Online sales mean the logistics of e-commerce businesses are totally different from the needs of more traditional shopping and retail enterprises. E-commerce presents a different type of business opportunity that many people want to capitalise on using their sales skills and the newer forms of funding support e-commerce in a better way than bank loans.

The good news is that modern forms of e-commerce funding are becoming more prevalent. The most successful e-commerce ventures are those that appreciate what kind of funding they need, the financial rules and laws relating to their enterprise, and how best to leverage the funding to scale their business.

Below we will look at 6 of the most popular ways to fund e-commerce businesses.

Crowdfunding

The reason why crowdfunding is a great option for e-commerce businesses is that it follows a modern formula for financing a business. Crowdfunding works by essentially obtaining funding from a crowd. This entails raising awareness of the business, then seeking contributions from various funders (often individuals and members of the public). Crowdfunding platforms like Kickstarter and Gofundme facilitate the receipt and payment of the funding.

In essence, crowdfunding flips the conventional funding model over. Instead of starting with capital funding or a loan from a bank, and then taking the idea to the public. Crowdfunding starts with marketing the idea directly to the public and then raising the capital. For e-commerce enterprises this is especially useful as anyone with a good idea can gain traction on social media and acquire capital from investors.

Bootstrapping

Bootstrappers build their business with very little outside capital and investment. Instead, they self-fund their business idea and retain control of the business. Bootstrapping is a simple and flexible strategy but can lead to financial strains and high levels of stress. Normally, ventures that rely on bootstrapping will rely on personal funds and cash flow from the company to scale the business. A famous example of a successful bootstrapping business is Spanx. However, this funding option is not an option for all e-commerce businesses as it requires owners to have a large capital sum to invest in the business from the outset. Remember, not having enough working capital can be disastrous for sales and growth and can ultimately be detrimental to the health of the business.

Equity Finance

Equity financing is exactly what it says: finance in return for equity in the business. This is a very traditional form of financial investment and is utilised by many startup businesses. Equity financing can be difficult to secure as new businesses do not have the evidential documentation a successful business will have. For online businesses, they may often find that trade is variable and there are no fixed assets or real estate property to secure any financing against. For anyone considering equity finance it is important to evaluate the level of funding that you can raise, and the extent of equity you will be handing over.

Grants

Grants are a great way to fund an e-commerce business, as they are usually non-returnable and act as a great investment into the business without losing control. However, if you want to apply for grants successfully you need to make sure you meet all the relevant criteria for the grant. As expected, grants are fiercely competitive and depend on what kind of business you have. You might find there are more grants available for those types of businesses that support socio-political issues, such as sustainability, green initiatives and charity functions.

The main benefit of grant funding is that you do not need to pay it back, it is capital that is free from interest and costs. Applying for grants is a lengthy and complex process and there is no guarantee of success. It is always best to research fully any grant opportunities and fine tune your business model and documentation before any application. Bear in mind that some grant funding also requires match funding from the business.

Revenue Sharing

Revenue sharing is a fairly new funding model that is particularly popular with e-commerce businesses that operate via websites across different territories (ie United Kingdom, United States, China etc). The way revenue sharing works is that funding is provided, and in return the business offers the financier a share of future revenues. Repayments are tied to the level of revenue to be generated. So, if revenue increases so too the repayments increase, and if the revenue falls the repayments also come down. The reason many e-commerce businesses like the revenue sharing model is that there is no requirement to give shares or equity to the investors and the business owners can retain full control of the venture.

Bank Loans

Bank loans are the traditional form of funding businesses have always used. They facilitate raising capital funding via borrowing. Usually, the loan is repaid via regular repayments that include interest and other fees. The difficulty with this model of funding is that it is prohibitive to those who adhere to Islamic finance and do not want to incur interest charges, and also bank loans are not always accessible for new e-commerce businesses. This means that the terms on offer are not always competitive. For anyone considering a bank loan, you need to make sure you research what the terms and conditions of the loan are and think about what level of debt you are comfortable with.

Whatever funding option you decide to pursue, you need to make sure that the capital raised meets the needs of the e-commerce business and that you do not fully lose control.

As more and more people attempt to get their foot onto the property ladder, this article will examine in detail the alternatives to conventional mortgages. In recent years there has been significant growth in alternatives to traditional mortgages, and what this means in principle is more choice for those looking to purchase assets or property in a Sharia compliant way.

There are many different reasons why people look for alternatives to mortgages:

• Flexibility: people want more flexibility when it comes to financing property or asset purchases.
• Accessibility: for some investors, alternatives to interest-based mortgage products are problematic as they contravene Islamic finance rules and ethical investment principles.
• Cost: alternative mortgage products can be cheaper overall than the standard mortgage products available in the UK, especially for those with poor credit scores.
• Less risky: there is sometimes less risk associated with alternative mortgages.

ALTERNATIVE MORTGAGES - WHY?

A conventional mortgage arrangement exists as a loan between a lender (bank) and an individual or company. The lender lends you the money to buy the property and in return, the borrower repays the money they have borrowed plus interest.

The mortgage loan itself is secured against the property and against the value of the property.

For many potential homeowners, a conventional mortgage is not a viable option, especially those looking for Islamic finance or ethical mortgages.

One of the main reasons traditional mortgages are shunned is that they are interest-centred and therefore not Sharia compliant. This has led to Muslims and ethical investors looking for alternative financial products to source funding when buying a property.

Interest is strictly prohibited under Islamic finance rules, so Muslims have had to look outside the traditional mortgage market in order to secure funding for their real estate and asset purchases.

However, it is not only Muslims who are looking at the market for alternatives to traditional mortgage products and services. As the ethical finance market continues to grow, many ethical investors and purchasers are also looking to secure funding that comes without hefty interest payments and charges.

Islamic banks and products under the Islamic finance banner are often considered to be a safer option than the finance options available on the mainstream finance market. The reason for this is that they are seen as less risky and less speculative.

Let's have a look at the alternatives out there and whether or not they are deemed to be halal or haram under Sharia rules.

Buy To Let Loans

Buy-to-let mortgage loans are designed for those people or businesses who want to purchase real estate properties with the purpose of renting the property out. Once the property is let, the homeowner then generates revenue through the rent payments they receive from the tenant.

Normally, these types of mortgages are based on higher interest rates than conventional mortgages and for this reason alone they are not Sharia compliant and are deemed to be haram.

There are some Islamic banks within the UK that offer a buy-to-let mortgage product, and if you want to review what is on offer you need to make sure that the product is 100% Sharia compliant.

Certainly, conventional buy-to-let mortgages that include interest in the repayment structure are not permissible for Muslims.

Home Purchase Plans

Home purchase plans are structured to avoid the charging and paying of interest. Normally a home purchase plan will involve the bank and the homeowner taking part in a shared investment strategy.

The bank, or financial institution, will purchase the property outright on behalf of the homeowner. The bank and the homeowner will agree the payments that the homeowner will make to the bank in lieu of repayment.

The homeowner will then make the repayments to the bank until they have paid off the pre-agreed price of the property. Once all the payments have been made the homeowner will own the property outright.

Home purchase plans give customers the opportunity to get on the property ladder in a halal and Sharia compliant way.

This type of co-ownership arrangement means the bank and the borrower share the risk and no interest is payable.

Shared Ownership Schemes

A shared ownership mortgage enables the purchaser to buy a share of the property. The purchaser then pays rent on the remaining share which is often owned by a non-profit organisation such as a registered social housing provider.

Shared ownership schemes were developed to enable people to get on the property ladder in an affordable way.

When structured correctly, shared ownership mortgages can be halal. If the share (of ownership) being purchased is clearly defined, and the rent on the remaining share is based on payments which are fair then this could be considered a halal alternative to an interest-based mortgage.

Make sure that the rental payments do not attract any interest, and that the terms and conditions of the ownership scheme are clear and concise. In the United Kingdom, shared ownership schemes are regulated and can often be an effective way to get on the property ladder.

If you are interested in a shared ownership scheme, look to see if they are being offered in your local area, and then look to see if any Islamic banks are offering shared ownership services.

Guarantor Mortgages

Guarantor mortgages are for those people who are unable to purchase a property, or secure funding to make the purchase, on their own.

A guarantor is involved who guarantees that they will repay the mortgage loan amount if the borrower does not make the payments.

Usually, the guarantor is a family member or close friend.

Whilst Islamic finance does permit the concept of a guarantor, in order for the service to be halal it needs to follow Sharia rules relating to such transactions. For example, a guarantor can be involved in a joint purchase transaction. In this type of financial transaction, the guarantor owns a share of the property and the risks are shared.

This is a musharakah arrangement - that is a profit-sharing arrangement or partnership.

If the guarantor mortgage is simply one where the guarantor guarantees the loan repayments with zero ownership rights then this is not permissible under Sharia rules.

Crowdfunding

Crowdfunding is a relatively new alternative to conventional mortgages. In its very basic form, crowdfunding operates by way of a collection of funds from a crowd of people (investors).

Whilst historically, investment markets have tended to be reliant on interest. However, Islamic crowdfunding is an activity that is deemed to be halal. Funds collected from a community have never been prohibited. In fact, crowdfunding in its very essence can have a positive social impact and this is a key principle of Islamic finance - social responsibility and ethical finance.

Anyone considering crowdfunding should ensure that the crowdfunding arrangement is set up to be fully Sharia compliant.

Self-Build Mortgages

Self-build mortgages are for those people who want to build their own homes. What this means in principle is that the loan is released to the borrower in stages that coincide with the stages of the build taking place. The final loan amount if based on the value of the property once it has been fully completed.

This type of alternative to the conventional mortgage is not halal as it still incurs the same type of interest payment as a standard up-front mortgage does.

Conclusions

Muslims have been wanting Sharia compliant alternatives to standard mortgages for many years. To address this, banks in England and other western economies have developed Sharia compliant alternatives that enable Muslim and ethical investors to buy a house or a business property/asset.

Halal alternatives to interest-based mortgages have several unique features. They are less risky, less speculative, and more socially responsible.

When it comes to investment strategies, ethical investing (also known as impact investing) is gaining traction. Some commentators have credited the likes of Greta Thunberg for the increase in demand for impact investment products, but this type of investing has been around for centuries in religious communities and societies.

Impact and ethical investments concentrate on approaches and strategies that facilitate inclusion and integration. As a result, the transaction has a positive impact on the social and economic environment. The investment itself is deemed to be one which benefits the investor and the wider community.

For investors looking to align their ethics and values with their financial output, they want to be sure that their portfolio grows in a sustainable way that supports their role as an ethical consumer and investor. Many mainstream funds do not offer ethical products and services, but the tide is changing fast and there are more companies offering bespoke ethical funds for discerningly ethical investors.The main benefits of ethical/ impact investing include the following:

• The values of companies and investors can be aligned
• Companies committed to social causes can be supported
• There is a feel good factor associated with ethical investments
• For religious communities, ethical investments are compliant with religious rules relating to investing (Sharia rules for Muslims)
• Ethical funds are a real catalyst for change
• The financial outlay does what it says on the label - ethical investment

Socially Responsible Investments

Socially responsible investing is a term associated closely with ethical investing. Socially responsible investment has a social conscience and does not negatively impact society. There are many companies on the market that offer investors the opportunity to invest in funds that provide positive social change and impact.

Of course, for Muslim investors socially responsible ventures have always been on the agenda, even when the opportunities to invest responsibly were not widely available on various platforms. Islamic finance dictates that Muslims should not invest in any project that could be detrimental to individuals or society as a whole. This is part of a much broader Islamic value-based social system. Muslims are instructed to safeguard society, the environment and make ethical choices that do not negatively impact society.

Ethical Investments

The definition of ethical investing is centered on the core concept that it is possible to align your financial goals with your moral and ethical values. Ethical ventures are focused on ensuring that the primary filter when selecting opportunities relating to money is based on ethical principles and considerations. There is a demand for increased transparency when it comes to shares, trusts, stocks, bonds and returns.

Used interchangeably with socially responsible and impact investing, ethical investments require due diligence before the capital is actually spent. Assessing whether a fund is ethical is based on using certain environmental, social, and governance criteria which can help you decide whether your investment is, indeed, ethical and socially responsible.

What ethical investment facilitates is the ability for individuals to allocate their capital with companies and funds that align with their own personal beliefs. One example of this is investors who want to avoid industries deemed to be unethical such as gambling, porn, weapons, and alcohol.

For Muslims, ethical ventures go further and also seek to ensure that the investments are compliant with the principles of Islamic finance and Sharia law.

Islamic Finance And Ethical Investments

Whilst ethical transactions may appear to be a relatively new concept in the West, Islamically, ethical investments have been a central principal of Islamic finance for centuries.

Historically, religion and ethical investing have been aligned. Islamic finance prohibits any financing of industries deemed to be haram.

Socially responsible investing and Islamic finance have seen rapid growth in recent decades, and it is no coincidence that the two go hand in hand. Islamic finance centres on principles of social responsibility and impact. This is achieved through principles of sustainability, positive impact, and strong governance.

More and more investors are joining Muslim investors in looking for ethical funds, and funds that offer green funds, or those that support the environment positively.

In recent years, the growth of ethical investing has been fuelled by religion AND social views. Social trends that have begun to lean towards ethics, environmental impact, and transparency have meant that ethical investments have become more mainstream.

In the 90s there was a move away from funds and ventures in the fuel and coal industries, and industries using animal testing, as these were seen as being harmful to the environment and society as a whole. Moving away from environmentally damaging industries was seen as a way of problem-solving some of the damage caused by the operations of these industries.

Sharia Compliant Investments

Ethical halal investing focuses on socially responsible principles, prohibiting:

1. Riba (interest)
2. Gharar (speculation)
3. Financial transactions in industries deemed to be haram such as the tobacco, alcohol and gambling industries

Environmental, Social, And Governance Considerations

In order to assess whether your portfolio is indeed socially responsible and ethical ,there are certain criteria that you can use. The criteria can broadly be divided under three main categories - environmental, social, and governance.

Investors need to review a broad variety of behaviors to understand if the investment is indeed sustainable, responsible, and socially impactful.

ENVIRONMENTAL

Environmental factors to look out when investing include assessing the impact of the investment on the following:

• Climate
• Pollution
• Waste
• Water stress
• Energy use
• Renewable energy
• Conservation
• Carbon footprint and ecological footprint
• Local economic policies

Environmental criteria will assist investors and companies to ascertain the impact of their ventures on the wider environment. Ethical companies should be aware of the environmental impact of their investments by using the criteria above to ensure that the risks are being identified, assessed, mitigated, and managed.

For example, investing in land development may seem like an ethical project, but what if the development adversely impacts local populations, natural resources, and contamination?

GOVERNANCE

In similar vein, anyone investing with a company will want to ensure that the company they use has a very transparent and accurate governance structure in place. Without strong governance, there is less accountability when it comes to ensuring that the investments you make are socially responsible.

The financial reporting and accounting methods, shareholders involvement, accountability, and financial management must have clarity and be transparent. For Muslims, they will also want to ensure that the investment company does engage in any investment behaviours deemed to be haram under Sharia law and Islamic finance rules, and ensure that haram industries are avoided.

When examining the practices of companies and businesses claiming to have ethical investment services and products, the following criteria should be carefully examined:

• The ethical and moral stance and values of the company
• The diversity within the company, shareholders, and board members
• The voting rights of shareholders and profit sharing arrangements
• Previous governance records
• Tax treatment and financial transparency
• What anti-competition practices are in place
• How the company manages financial and ethical conflicts of interest
• Asset management strategies and choices
• How the company treats its customers and investors

SOCIAL

Social criteria focuses on the business relationships of the investment company/ investment and the social impact.

Socially responsible investing focuses on social values, the environment and good governance. Does the investment company you want to invest in hold similar values to you? How committed are they to ethical values? Do they uphold Islamic finance principles? Does the company donate to charities that align with your charitable focus?

When considering the social criteria, you need to look out for investment and financial impacts on the following:

• Supply chain labour
• Ethical sourcing
• Data and privacy
• Protocols relating to health and safety
• Impact and bonds with local communities and links with them
• Previous investment history and sectors invested in
• How the investment portfolio is socially responsible

Ethical Investing

In order to ensure that the investment you make is ethical, you need to ensure that you do your research and analyze the historical, present, and predicted performance and standards of the investment you are interested in. Of course, there are many companies that offer ethical investment products, but that does not mean investors are absolved of their own personal responsibility to undertake research and ask their own questions.

Investors should:

• Review the mission statement of the investment company
• Check their track record of investments
• Review their ethical values and see if they align with your own
• Check if the company complies with laws and statutes
• Understand how ethical investments and funds operate

Is Ethical Investing Profitable

Ethical investing does not guarantee a profit. However, when it comes to the performance of ethical funds as compared to traditional investment funds, there does not appear any significant difference. In fact, ethical investments can sometimes outperform traditional investment funds.

The whole point of ethical investing is that you can invest your money in a way that yields positive results on society and also makes a profit. According to an article in the Guardian (December, 2021), in the United Kingdom alone, the annual spending on ethical services and products has exceeded £100 billion [1]. With the onset of the global pandemic and climate change, people are looking for ethical investments and industries far more than ever before.

The Future Of Investing

We have entered an era when socially responsible investing is increasingly in demand. The increase does not only relate to ethics and morals, but is also centered on principles of sustainability, investor goal-setting, values, protection of the natural environment, whilst still making money.

Gone are the days when investing in the stock market was solely for the purpose of generating income, with no thought for the impact of the investment. Modern ethical investors are keen to ensure their investments are transparent, socially responsible and with solid governance structures in place. Sustainable long term results are seen as aligning with the much broader objectives and principles within Islamic finance and the wider society.

For too long, investments have focused on profit margins over values. Ethical investing means that profits can still be prioritized, but they ranked alongside ethics and values and do not lead to the social exclusion of marginalized groups or countries.

Tips To Invest Ethically

Investing ethically is about more than making sure your investment appears to be ethical. It is focused on investors learning about what it is they are investing in, the social and environmental impact, and holding investment companies to account.

The following tips will help you avoid investments that do not align with your personal values and goals:

• Assess and identify your values and principles
• Learn about ethical investments and how they operate
• Build your investment portfolio carefully with sustainability and social responsibility in mind
• If you have ISAs or pensions review where they are invested
• Check your investment strategy - do you want to focus on start-ups or existing ethical investment companies?
• Make sure you diversify your portfolio across regions and sectors
• Planning your investment in advance

Sources Used In This Report

[1] UK annual spending on ethical products surpasses £100bn for first time [The Guardian, Dec. 2021] [https://www.theguardian.com/money/2021/dec/31/uk-annual-spending-on-ethical-products-surpasses-100bn...]