Islamic Finance and Impact Investing
According to reports, global sustainable investment assets had exceeded $30 trillion by 2018, driven primarily by a surge in values-based investing [1]. The core concept behind values-based investing is that investments are made around a shared set of values present in an investment philosophy. This topic is even more prevalent now, as sustainable investing has been identified as key for the post-pandemic recovery. In this article, we provide an overview of a rapidly growing area within values-based investing called impact investing, that has grown to an estimated total market size globally of over $715 billion in 2020 [2]. We then compare the core values that are inherent in Sharia-compliant (i.e. Islamic) investing with those of other values-based investing strategies.
Overview of impact investing
The Global Impact Investing Network (GIIN) defines impact investments as "investments made into companies, organizations, and funds with the intention to generate social and environmental impact alongside a financial return".
Whereas financial returns are typically measured using commonly used metrics (ROE, ROI, etc.), what distinguishes impact investing is the measurement of social returns as well. Within this context, the main points to consider when measuring social returns are according to the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) [3] are:
- Outputs are activities carried out by an organization or project. Outputs are meaningless without context. Let's take the example of building a solar power or solar farm to provide reliable power to communities for the first time.
- Outcomes on the other hand are short or intermediate-term, tangible effects observed by project beneficiaries. A tangible effect from the construction of the solar farm would be for example a reduction in energy costs for the project beneficiaries.
- Impacts are broader, more long-term and sweeping changes usually affecting a larger groups of people or community. Measuring impact in this sense is extremely difficult, particularly with regards to being able to isolate and quantify changes that are directly related to a project (i.e. holding all else constant).
Among all social returns impact is the most difficult to measure and hence there is an increasing focus in impact investing on measuring outcomes.
Foundations of Islamic finance
Islamic finance or Sharia-compliant finance involves financing activities that comply with the Sharia (Islamic law). For instance some prohibited activities include that financing must not involve:
- Riba or an increase in capital without any real services provided - akin to "usury" or unjust exploitative gains.
- Gharar or speculation or chance is not allowed - this includes for example excessive uncertainty regarding essential elements of a contract, such as price in a contract of sale.
- Haram (Forbidden) businesses or industries - This practically involves an exclusionary screening process as it is forbidden to finance companies that derive significant income from the sale of alcohol, tobacco, pork, weapons, gambling, pornography and interest-based financial institutions.
It is important to note that in Islam, money has no inherent value on its own. Money increases or decreases in value only when joined with other resources for the purposes of productive activities. All transactions must be based on real economic activity. Islamic finance also goes beyond the purpose of financing to cover the structure of financing. Contemporary Islamic finance incorporates these principles and others in a wide variety of products to meet the growing global demand for Sharia-compliant investment and financing.
Other values-based investing strategies
Socially Responsible Investing (SRI) also known as ethical investing, involves avoiding industries that negatively affect the environment and its people.This includes actively removing or choosing investments from a portfolio based on specific ethical criteria. SRI exclusionary screening avoids for example companies that produce or invest in alcohol, tobacco, gambling and weapons. Environmental, Social & Governance (ESG) investing grew out of investment philosophies such as SRI. ESG however is a framework for evaluating companies and not a standalone investment strategy. It is intentionally neutral - Not faith, country or industry specific.
Areas of overlap
Islamic finance & SRI show some similarities in their objectives (do good, avoid harm), methods (exclusionary screening) & claims (an emphasis on ethics). As mentioned earlier however, Islamic finance goes beyond the purpose of financing to cover the structure of financing as well. Islamic screening also goes over and above SRI screening to exclude other sectors such as interest-based financial institutions for example.
Similarities between impact investing and Islamic finance on the other hand stem from a a strong emphasis in Islam on social and economic justice as well as supporting any action with a view to protecting the planet and the environment. One area of overlap for example is around access to finance for the world's populations that are directly or indirectly kept out of formal financial sectors. Another interesting development is the issuance of green sukuks that are Sharia-compliant investments in renewable energy and other environmental assets. They address Sharia concerns for protecting the environment. It is however important to note that more has to be done in the Islamic finance space to measure impact and in particular measuring outcomes.
What is the role of Qardus?
Qardus is a social impact investment platform that promotes financial inclusion. The SMEs we finance in the UK were prior to this financially excluded due to the lack of financial products that conform with their ethics & values. Financial inclusion is positioned prominently as an enabler of other development goals in the 2030 UN Sustainable Development Goals (UN SDGs) such as regarding SDG 8 on promoting economic growth & jobs & SDG 10 on reducing inequality.
Along these lines, a recent report by Oxford Economics has also attempted to measure the outcome of lending on another crowdfunding (P2P) platform [4]. The report on page 9 indicated for every £1 million lent on their platform, there was a £2 million contribution to GDP, 37 jobs were supported, and £635k were generated in taxes.
[1] http://www.gsi-alliance.org/
[2] https://thegiin.org/research/publication/impinv-survey-2020
[3] https://www.undp.org/content/dam/istanbul/docs/Islamic_Finance_Impact.pdf
[4] https://www.oxfordeconomics.com/recent-releases/1074dfbd-d5e1-4498-abd3-95b399ad63fc
Receive insights on ethical financing and Islamic finance directly to your inbox.
Explore more news
WHAT IS ISLAMIC FINANCE?
Islamic finance is a financial system based on Sharia principles - the religious law enshrined within Islam. Islamic finance offers an alternative financial system to the conventional systems, and is based on fairness, transparency, and social justice.
WHO USES ISLAMIC FINANCE?
Islamic finance is a growing industry and is used extensively by Muslims throughout the world. However, more and more non Muslims are also looking at Islamic finance services as they want to operate in a more ethical way.
DO MUSLIMS PAY INTEREST IN THE UK?
Whilst Muslims are discouraged from paying or earning interest in any form under Islamic finance rules, many Muslims in the West do pay interest. However, more and more Muslims are becoming aware of alternative financial systems and products that enable them to access loans and financial services that are compliant with Sharia law.
CAN MUSLIMS TAKE LOANS?
Yes, of course. Taking a loan is not prohibited in Islam. However, it is important to ensure that the loan terms are compliant with Sharia rules.
HOW DO ISLAMIC LOANS WORK?
Islamic loans are structured and developed to ensure they are halal - that is they do not contravene any rules in Islam relating to finances. For example, an Islamic loan will not have any element of interest attached to it.
WHY CAN'T MUSLIMS EARN INTEREST?
In Islam, interest is seen as exploitative as it leads to the lender making a profit at the expense of the borrower. Islam views interest as the unfair accumulation of the wealthy and this can lead to financial distress for those who need to borrow money. Interest is viewed as being against the promotion of social justice and economic fairness which are key concepts underpinning Islamic finance.
WHAT IS HARAM IN ISLAMIC FINANCE?
The following are deemed haram in Islam: riba/interest, gambling, excessive uncertainty, investment in haram industries or practices.
WHAT IS ETHICAL FINANCE?
While there is no universally accepted definition of ethical finance, the Ethical Finance Hub describes it as "A system of financial management or investment that seeks qualitative outcomes other than purely the management of returns. Outcomes sought may reflect ideas from faith, social, environmental and governance theories."
IS ISLAMIC OR SHARIA-COMPLIANT FINANCE ETHICAL?
The World Bank mentions that Islamic finance is ethical, sustainable, environmentally and socially responsible finance. It promotes risk sharing, connects the financial sector with the real economy, and emphasizes financial inclusion and social welfare.
While there is no universally accepted definition of ethical finance, the Ethical Finance Hub describes it as "A system of financial management or investment that seeks qualitative outcomes other than purely the management of returns. Outcomes sought may reflect ideas from faith, social, environmental and governance theories."
The success of your business depends on three factors - your product, your marketing and your funding. Most businesses fail not because of their product or their marketing, but because of cash flow problems. It's poor funding that brings them down.As an entrepreneur and business owner, it's easier to get excited about your products and their potential, rather than about your finances. But without secure financial foundations, that excitement can soon turn to frustration.Cash will flow into your business as you sell. But in order to sell you first need money to invest in stock, people and premises. Whether yours is a startup company or you're looking to expand, you need funds to invest in advance of starting to see sales coming in.There are many different forms of business funding. Here are some of those most commonly used by business owners.
Your own money
Many small businesses rely on the founder or owner providing at least some of the capital. There's always an element of risk in starting or growing your business and by funding it yourself, you're not accountable to anyone else. This does mean, however, that if the business doesn't grow as you hope, you risk losing some or all of the money you've invested.Using your own money allows you to be in full control of how you run the business. However, you could be missing out on the advice and guidance that's often available when you're borrowing from someone else.If you're starting a new business, or expanding your current business into a new market, you should anticipate costs being higher than you expect and allow a generous contingency to cover the unexpected. Small businesses don't grow without some mistakes being made, and these cost money. In the longer term, you learn from these mistakes, and they help you make better decisions in the future. However, if you're working on a very tight budget, these costs could seriously hold you back.
Friends and family
You may know people who are open to investing in your business. Some may be willing to give you a loan, quite possibly on generous terms such as with low or no interest and flexible repayment terms. Others may want equity in return for their money - they effectively become co-owners of the business, although probably only owning a small slice.It's for you to determine whether friends and family money is appropriate. It can be very convenient, and flexible, but at the same time you need to be aware of how financial arrangements can affect your relationships with people close to you. If all goes well, there's unlikely to be a problem. But if the business struggles, they may become concerned or even demand some of the investment back.When borrowing from friends and family, it's a good idea to draw up a document that will help to set everyone's expectations, both for how much involvement they will have in running the business, and how and when they will be repaid. They should be made fully aware of the risks involved when putting money into a new venture.
Grants
A grant is money that does not usually need to be repaid. There are various local and national grant schemes available to businesses, usually linked to startups, growth or innovation. They can range in size from just a few hundred pounds to many thousands, even millions.While grants can be hugely beneficial to entrepreneurs, they can also be time-consuming to apply for and sometimes come with quite stringent conditions. Many grants are based on match funding, meaning they won't cover the full cost of a specific project - you are expected to raise some of the funds from elsewhere.
Secured loan
A secured loan is where you borrow from a bank or other institution and if you fail to make repayments the lender has rights over an asset that you own, such as your home or business property. Because the loan is secured on an asset the lender has confidence they will get some or all of their money back, should you run into financial problems.It can take a few weeks to set up a secured loan because legal documents must be drawn up and signed off. The advantage of such a loan is that because it's secured, you may get more favourable terms, such as lower interest charges or a longer repayment term. The downside is that if you fail to keep up with repayments, your property is at risk. Most lenders aren't in a hurry to sell your asset, as they'd rather you found ways to keep up your repayments. However, they have that option if they need it.Applying for a loan will usually require you to provide considerable information about the financial position of your business, along with projections about future income and cash flow.
Unsecured loans
An unsecured loan is where you borrow without providing an asset as security. However, most banks and other financial institutions do ask for a director's guarantee or equivalent. This is where the director agrees to take personal responsibility for repaying the loan, should the business be unable to do so.Because it's not linked to an asset, an unsecured loan can be set up more quickly. However, for the same reason the amount you can borrow is likely to be lower, and the terms less favourable.These loans can come in various forms, including business credit cards, which are effectively an indefinite loan where you choose how much you want to borrow and repay on a monthly basis, subject to certain limits.
Venture capital and angel investors
Venture capitalists and angel investors are individuals or groups seeking to put money into businesses with growth potential. Venture capitalists are investing funds on behalf of a third-party and as such, they are more risk averse. They're looking for evidence that the business has a promising future. An angel investor, or business angel, is a high-net-worth individual who is often more open to getting involved with a startup and will take a bigger risk.The money they give you is not a loan. They are effectively buying part of the business - they have a stake in the equity of your business, meaning they become co-owners. This can have some implications for the amount of control that you have over how you run the business, but can be beneficial, giving you a source of advice and support, and it can provide a strong incentive for you to be more successful.Both VCs and angel investors will make a careful assessment of your business and its potential, and they know that by investing they are taking a risk. At some point they will want to be repaid - often when the business is sold.
Crowdfunding and peer-to-peer finance
The internet has made it much easier to connect people who want to invest, often small amounts, with businesses looking to raise working capital - the cash they need to operate and grow.Crowdfunding is where a business wants to raise money to launch a specific product. The business can be either a startup or an established firm. It launches a crowdfunding appeal to people likely to be interested in the product. The funders typically don't have a right to be repaid if the business or product fails, but if it all goes well, they get access to the product on preferential terms. Two of the most well-known crowdfunding platforms are Indiegogo and Kickstarter.Peer-to-peer finance matches people and businesses with money to lend with others looking to borrow. Top peer-to-peer sites include Zopa and Funding Circle.Any business looking to raise money through crowdfunding or peer-to-peer systems is usually required to undergo credit checks and other financial assessments, to ensure the risk to investors is minimised.
Finding the right way to fund your business
Finding the right way to fund the plans for your small business depends on many different factors, including how much you need to raise, when and how you'll be able to repay it, and your attitude towards giving up some ownership or control of the business. Potential lenders or investors will be interested in your business history, your credit rating and your growth potential. Each will have different attitudes to risk.
Small business funding with Qardus
We provide funds to small businesses with a proven track record that are looking to grow. Our finance is ethical and community based, providing funding from £50k to £200k with terms of between six and thirty-six months. Our funding process follows Islamic principles, meaning we don't charge interest and we don't work with industries considered harmful to society, such as alcohol, tobacco and gambling. The funding is Sharia-compliant, making it an attractive option for Muslim business owners, but we also fund others outside the Muslim community.We offer fast, flexible and affordable unsecured finance, firmly grounded in ethical principles.
The growth of Sharia-compliant finance services has led to a similar growth in technology that is advancing and supporting sharia compliancy for businesses. Sharia-compliant fintech has emerged as driver of innovation and ensuring businesses can operate efficiently and within the rules of Islamic finance.
By leveraging technology, Sharia-compliant businesses are able to operate in a compliant way whilst also ensuring they are not left behind in the fintech revolution.
In addition, businesses can use technology to offer their clients and customers opportunities to become more engaged in socially responsible and ethical financial activities.
Technology that supports Sharia-compliant businesses to operate also supports Islamic finance principles relating to money, financial transactions, and any form of investment.
WHAT IS SHARIA-COMPLIANT TECHNOLOGY?
When we talk about Sharia-compliant financial technology (fintech), we refer to technological solutions that adhere to Islamic finance rules relating to Sharia-compliant transactions and services.
The fintech can take the form of online tools or cutting edge technology that includes artificial intelligence, blockchain, online banking, Sharia compliant banking, and apps that support Muslim businesses.
Sharia-compliant technology needs to ensure it is:
- Compliant
- Transparent
- In accordance with Islamic finance rules
- Accessible
Technology that is Sharia-compliant plays a critical role in ensuring that Muslim businesses can expand their reach and continue to grow. For many years, Muslim entrepreneurs and SMEs in the West had no alternative to the conventional form of finance structures offered by Western banking services.
These services and products were mainly not compliant with Sharia rules as they relied heavily on interest based lending (riba) which is strictly prohibited in Islam.
With the advent and growth of Islamic finance, the fintech industry has developed many different types of technology to support businesses and customers who want to carry out business transactions whilst remaining true to their Islamic principles.
The Intersection Of Ethics And Fintech
The combination of technology and ethics is a key component of Sharia compliant finance. Islamic finance rules are underpinned by concepts of social justice and ethics, and it therefore follows that technology must also play its role in implementing and amplifying ethics.
Leveraging technology within Islamic finance via fintech platforms and services means that businesses are increasing their ethical standing and social responsibility.
Sharia compliant fintech platforms and products needs to ensure that interest is prohibited, excessive uncertainty or ambiguity is avoided, and there is complete transparency. What technology facilitates within the Islamic finance sector, is efficiency, broader accessibility, and transparency. These are all key ethical concepts within the Islamic finance framework.
Smart contracts and decentralised platforms lead to greater accessibility and efficiency. They take the control away from large organisations and ensure that previously excluded financial groups can partake in business, whether as owners or customers.
Fintech Solutions
Technological solutions enable automated compliance, increased monitoring, reporting, real time tracking, and enhanced risk assessment and mitigation. These all align with the ethical values of Islamic finance and Sharia rules.
As technology and fintech solutions continue to evolve and come to the market, they are playing a crucial role in the accessibility of Sharia-compliant business finance. This is done through technology that enhances transparency, accessibility and offers innovation.
Let's have a look at some of the solutions that enable businesses to operate in a Sharia-compliant way:
- Smart contracts: smart contracts facilitate automation and transparency for all parties and therefore reducing any risk of exploitation and future disputes.
- Blockchain: blockchain technology is centralised this means control moves away from the conventional bank model and market. Blockchain also reduces the risk of fraud.
- Digital banking: online banking platforms have not only introduced global audiences to more finance options, but these platforms are often user friendly and Sharia compliant. Customers and businesses are able to access current accounts, business accounts and financial solutions at the press of a few buttons.
- Crowdfunding: these platforms are fast emerging as a Sharia compliant form of raising capital and investment. Our Sharia-compliant investment guide explains more about how these funding routes work and what to look for. Many Muslim businesses and ventures across the world have created crowdfunding campaigns when they have not been able to find Sharia-compliant funding options for their project.
-
- AI: the future is definitely becoming more automated and managed. When it comes to the financial services economy, it is fair to say AI has the potential to revolutionise the products and services that already exist.
- Regulation tech (Regtech): for many Muslim businesses including those in the healthtech sector (dentists, pharmaceutical companies, health centres) regtech is critical. Not only does it ensure regulatory compliance, but is also essential for monitoring and maintaining Sharia compliancy.
Islamic Fintech And Social Innovation
The basic principles that underpin Islamic finance are rooted in financial stability and security. For businesses, this includes an element of corporate social responsibility. The advances in technology mean that fintech has provided businesses with the ability to compete on equal or better ground than those operating in the conventional banking system.
Technological innovations including online banking platforms have enhanced compliance with Sharia law. For example, online platforms have led to increased:
- Transparency
- Accessibility of Sharia compliant products
- Automation of compliance monitoring and reporting
- Secure transactions
- Educational information
- Customised Sharia-compliant solutions
Technology For Businesses And Individuals
It's not only businesses that are benefiting from compliant fintech solutions.
Consumers and customers are also becoming deeply ingrained in new and innovative digital ecosystems. Just consider how many people use online banking apps to monitor their spending, make obligatory payments such as zakat and sadaqa online, or donate their accrued interest payments in halal ways.
For businesses within the health sector such as dentists and pharmaceutical organisations, technology has enabled them to operate in a Sharia compliant way.
Technology aids businesses to plan their strategy whilst also ensuring they continue to adhere to Islamic finance principles.Technology is used to improve accuracy and efficiency by providing real time data. Sharia compliance can often be automated within the technological systems those in the health sector use.
Stay informed on finance
